Kai Havertz went to ground inside the area in the first half at the Emirates Stadium, with the match still goalless, after being pulled back by Nobel Mendy as he made a run in behind. The offence was not spotted by the officials at the time, and VAR advised referee Farai Hallam to halt play and look at the incident on the pitchside monitor.
After reviewing the footage, Hallam accepted that Havertz had been fouled but decided he was in an offside position, and Hull were given a free-kick instead. According to the Mirror, a late goal from Martin Odegaard gave Arsenal the win, leaving them five points ahead at the top after 10 games.
What the panel decided
The Key Match Incidents Panel, which meets after every round of Premier League fixtures, voted 5-0 that a penalty should have been awarded and 5-0 that the on-field call should have been overturned, Daily Cannon reports.
In its explanation, the panel accepted that Havertz was "clearly in an offside position" but found there was "a clear and impactful holding action by Mendy before any potential offside offence". It added: "Given the chronology of events, a penalty should have been awarded."
The panel supported the VAR's decision to send Hallam to the monitor, but judged the conclusion he reached after that review to be incorrect. It also set out the principle behind the ruling: standing in an offside position is not in itself an offence, and a player is only penalised once involved in active play, so a foul committed beforehand is the offence that gets punished.
The same panel backed the decision not to give Havertz a penalty for a separate, earlier challenge by Mendy in the same match, according to Daily Cannon.
A third penalty call against Arsenal
The Mirror reports that the Hull incident is the third penalty decision this season that the panel has found went against Arsenal.
It also reviewed the spot-kick Sunderland were given in September's meeting at the Stadium of Light, which Arsenal won 2-0 through second-half goals from Bruno Guimaraes and Bukayo Saka. Ezri Konsa was adjudged to have pulled Dan Ballard to the ground at a corner, but David Raya saved Enzo Le Fee's attempt. The panel later decided the penalty should not have been awarded, because Ballard had also been holding Konsa.
Daily Cannon reports that the panel has now flagged five incorrect decisions across Arsenal's 10 league games, four of them going against Mikel Arteta's team.
The one decision that went Arsenal's way concerned the 1-0 win over Liverpool, when the panel decided by 4-1 that Jurrien Timber's pull on Alexander Isak should have resulted in a penalty, and by 3-2 that VAR Stuart Attwell should have recommended an on-field review by referee Andy Madley.
Webb due in front of clubs
The Daily Mail reports that the Premier League identified five incorrect decisions across the latest round of fixtures, which it describes as officials' worst weekend of the season so far, with the Hull call among them. Howard Webb, the boss of Pro Ref, is due to face the clubs on Thursday during a regular Premier League meeting.
The panel comprises one representative each from the Premier League and ProRef, plus three former managers or players.
Arsenal's next fixture is away to Newcastle United in the Premier League on Saturday 21 November, with a 17:30 kick-off at St. James' Park.
Photo: Photo2023 via Wikimedia Commons, CC0, resized.








Comments (0)
No comments yet — start the conversation.